The question of war in the social doctrine of the Catholic Church through the prism of the events of Russia's war against Ukraine and in the current theological reflections of ukrainian catholics
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.52761/2522-1558.2023.18.11Keywords:
social doctrine, Roman Catholic Church, Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, Russia's war against Ukraine, Ukrainian Catholics, experienceAbstract
The article analyzes the provisions on war in the social doctrine of the Catholic Church through the prism of the events of Russia's war against Ukraine and in the current theological reflections of Ukrainian Catholics. The purpose of the article is to clarify the possibilities of practical application of these provisions of the Catholic social doctrine in the situation of modern war in view of the assessment of their practical implementation by representatives of the RCC and UGCC in the context of today's war chronicle. The scientific novelty of the article is due to the consideration of doctrinal instructions regarding war, taking into account their evaluations by representatives of Catholics in today's Ukraine, who ponder theoretical questions "from the middle" of the practical experience of citizens of a country, against which the enemy has unleashed a brutal war. After all, only one's own experience of living in specific situations makes it possible to fully assess the degree of adequacy of theoretical provisions - actual reality. The achievement of scientific novelty is summarized in the conclusions: the corpus of the Compendium of Social Doctrine in its modern presentation (since 2004), as well as encyclicals and other documents of the Catholic Church of the 19th and 20th centuries, written by people who are representatives of the Euro-Atlantic cultural and civilization circle . Therefore, despite the potential of universality and timelessness (at least within the framework of the Christian worldview), these instructions can be understood and accepted rather by the recipients of the same circle, and do not take into account the entire mental complex of those who are actually outside it. That is probably why, similar to the written postulates of international organizations, the avant-garde builders of which are mainly the representative states of this same circle, the instructions of the Catholic social doctrine may not fully "work" in all situations of military conflicts. In particular, as it is now obvious, Russia has learned to use in its own interests fairly and humanely written laws and guidelines, secular and ecclesiastical, and to brutally violate them, to which both in the Catholic social doctrine and in the documents of international organizations, in the end, only one answer remains - armed power.
References
Baloh, P. (2022). Vatykan, vytoky skhidnoi polityky ta viina v Ukraini. Istorychna pravda. [The Vatican, the origins of Eastern politics and the war in Ukraine. Historical Truth]. Retrieved from https://www.istpravda.com.ua/articles/2022/06/16/161451// [in Ukrainian].
Baloh, P. (2022). Spravedlyva viina. Khrystyianska sluzhba poriatunku. [ Just War. Christian Rescue Service]. Retrieved from http://crs-center.org/spravedlyva-vijna/ [in Ukrainian].
Hlava UHKTs pro vyklyky viiny i dukhovnu borotbu. Patriarkhat. [Head of the UGCC on challenges of war and spiritual struggle. Patriarchate]. Retrieved from http://www.patriyarkhat.org.ua/statti-zhurnalu/hlava-uhkts-pro-vyklyky-vijny-i-duhovnu-borotbu/ [in Ukrainian].
Holik Roman (2022). Vipa yak zbroia: viina ta relihiia v kulturnii pam’iati 20 – pochatku 21 st. Naukovyi shchorichnyk «Istoriia relihii v Ukraini». Instytut relihiieznavstva – filiia Lvivskoho muzeiu istorii. T.1 № 32 (2022). [Religion as a weapon: war and religion in the cultural memory of the 20th and early 21st centuries. Scientific yearbook "History of Religions in Ukraine". The Institute of Religious Studies a branch of the Lviv Museum of History. Volume 1 No. 32 (2022)]. Retrieved from http://religio.org.ua/index.php/religio/article/view/1464 DOI: https://doi.org/10.33294/2523-4234-2022-32-1-51-63 [in Ukrainian].
«Katekhyzm khrystyianskoho voina» – zbirnyk zasad khrystyianskoho vchennia stosovno moralnykh aspektiv viiskovoi sluzhby v umovakh viiny. Patriarsha katekhytychna komisiia. Ukrainska Hreko-Katolytska Tserkva. [«Catechism of the christian warrior» - collection of the principles of christian teaching regarding the moral aspects of military service in the conditions of war. Patriarchal Catechetical Commission. Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church]. Retrieved from https://ct.ugcc.ua/catechism/catechism-books/40217 [in Ukrainian].
Kompendium sotsialnoi doktryny Tserkvy. [Compendium of the social doctrine of the Church]. K.: Kairos. 2004. [in Ukrainian].
Khrystyiany svitu i viina rosii z Ukrainoiu. Interviu z Yuriiem Pidlisnym. Patriarkhat. [Christians of the world and Russia's war with Ukraine. Interview with Yuriy Podlisny. Patriarchate]. 2022, №4 (491). Retrieved from http://www.patriyarkhat.org.ua/statti-zhurnalu/hrystyyany-svitu-i-vijna-rosiji-z-ukrajinoyu/ [in Ukrainian].
P’iasta R. & Lukashevskyi, V. (2022). Zakhyst Batkivshchyny u vchenni Katolytskoi Tserkvy. Dobryi pastyr. [Good parson]. № 17, 2022. Retrieved from http://journal.ifaiz.edu.ua/index.php/gp/article/view/379 DOI: https://doi.org/10.52761/2522-1558.2022.17.4 [in Ukrainian].
Shchurko Yurii, o. (2022). Naivnist patsyfizmu ta pryntsypy vedennia spravedlyvoi viiny. CREDO. [The naivety of pacifism and the principles of waging a just war. CREDO]. Retrieved from https://credo.pro/2022/05/319079 [in Ukrainian].
Zahrebelnyi, I. (2022). Chy potribna nam «nova teolohiia pislia Buchi». Politychna teolohiia. [Do we need a "new theology after Buchi". Political theology]. Retrieved from https://politteo.online/materialy/chy-potribna-nam-nova-teologiya-pislya-buchi/ [in Ukrainian].
Zahrebelnyi, I. (2022). Khrystyianske stavlennia do viiny. Politychna teolohiia. [Christian attitude to war. Political theology]. Retrieved from https://politteo.online/materialy/hrystyyanske-stavlennya-do-vijny/ [in Ukrainian].
Zahrebelnyi, I. (2022). Uroky dyskredytovanoho patsyfizmu. Politychna teolohiia. [Lessons of discredited pacifism. Political theology]. Retrieved from https://politteo.online/materialy/uroky-dyskredytovanogo-paczyfizmu/ [in Ukrainian].
Zelinskyi, A., o. (2022). Ne dozvolyty vlasnomu svitlu zghasnuty! Patriarkhat. 2-3 (490), 2022. [Don't let your own light go out! Patriarchate. 2-3 (490), 2022]. Retrieved from http://www.patriyarkhat.org.ua/statti-zhurnalu/ne-dozvolyty-vlasnomu-svitlu-zhasnuty/ [in Ukrainian].
«Z namy pravda. Z namy Boh!» - kapelan Andrii Zelinskyi pro moralnyi dukh biitsiv ZSU i pro te, yak ukraintsiam diiaty u viini. Relihiino-informatsiina sluzhba Ukrainy. [«The truth is with us. God is with us!» - chaplain Andriy Zelinskyi about the morale of the soldiers of the Armed Forces of Ukraine and how Ukrainians should act in war. Religious Information Service of Ukraine]. Retrieved from https://risu.ua/z-nami-pravda-z-nami-bog----kapelan-andrij-zelinskij-pro-moralnij-duh-bijciv-zsu-i-pro-te-yak-ukrayincyam-diyati-u-vijni_n127476. [in Ukrainian].